Agent Identity and Reasoning Events

Summary

Introduce a protocol-level AgentRef wire shape and a closed set of five agent.* reasoning events (agent.reasoned, agent.toolCalled, agent.toolReturned, agent.handoff, agent.decided). AgentRef identifies which agent took which turn inside a run; the five events expose agent decision-making to observers, debuggers, and replay without prescribing the agent runtime. The shape is additive to v1: pre-RFC-0002 runs simply omit the agent fields and continue to fold correctly.

Motivation

The v1 baseline (run-event.schema.json, run-snapshot.schema.json) is agent-agnostic: a node's started and completed events carry no record of _which_ agent the node delegated to. For single-agent or single-model deployments this is sufficient. As soon as a host adopts orchestrator-driven topologies (RFC 0006) or shared-context multi-agent patterns, several gaps appear:

1. Provenance. Audit and replay can't answer "which agent reasoned about this state?"
2. Tool-call attribution. When a node calls multiple tools across multiple sub-agents, observers can't disambiguate which agent's reasoning produced each call.
3. Cross-host portability. A2A composition (spec/v1/a2a-integration.md) needs a stable identity for the external agent; without an AgentRef shape, every host invents its own.
4. Handoff observability. Supervisor-worker handoffs are common in practice but invisible at the wire layer.

The fix lives in the protocol because hosts and clients on both ends of a run need to agree on the wire shape. Moving it to a host extension creates openwop. vs vendor. drift across implementations.

Proposal

§A AgentRef wire shape

AgentRef is the canonical identity record for an agent acting inside a run. Where present, it MUST conform to:

{
  "agentId": "string (required) — manifest agentId or host-local id",
  "agentSharing": "isolated | shared | shared:%shared% (optional)",
  "memoryRef": "string (optional, opaque) — host-resolvable handle for cross-run memory",
  "modelClass": "reasoning | writing | coding | research | classification | general (optional)"
}

§A1 agentId

Globally unique within the issuing host. Two namespace tiers are normative:

• Manifest agents. Names follow agent-manifest.schema.json (<tier>.<org>.<pack>.<agent> for vendor / community / private / local, or core.<name> for spec-canonical agents).
• Host-local agents. host:<id> is reserved for agents instantiated by the host without a pack manifest (e.g., a built-in orchestrator). Hosts MUST NOT accept host: IDs in pack manifests.

Clients MUST treat agentId as opaque; only the issuing host resolves it to a manifest or runtime.

§A8 agentSharing

Three values, closed enum:

• 'isolated' — the agent runs with a fresh context per node (default).
• 'shared' — the agent's context is shared across all nodes in the run.
• 'shared:<groupId>' — the agent's context is shared across nodes with the same groupId discriminator. groupId is opaque.

shared:<groupId> requires a groupId field on accompanying messages (see RFC 0005 §C).

§A14 Tool permission mapping

When toolAllowlist is declared on the manifest (agent-manifest.schema.json), hosts MUST filter the agent's tool surface to the allowlist before dispatch. The canonical filter receives the agent's harnessRole (host-defined) and returns the allowed tool set. Reference implementations expose this as ToolPermissionService.filterTools(harnessRole); the protocol does not constrain the name, only the result.

§F Confidence and escalation

Agents MAY emit a confidence field on agent.decided (range [0.0, 1.0]). Hosts compare confidence against a threshold to decide whether to escalate (e.g., raise an 'ask-user' orchestrator decision, RFC 0006 §C):

• Default threshold. 0.7.
• Per-agent threshold. confidence.defaultThreshold on the agent manifest overrides.
• Per-run threshold. RunOptions.configurable.escalationThreshold overrides both.

When confidence < threshold, the host MUST take exactly one action: emit an 'ask-user' OrchestratorDecision (if a runOrchestrator is configured), surface a 'clarification' interrupt (if not), or emit a cap.breached event with kind: 'confidence-escalation-suppressed' if the host has explicitly opted out of escalation via configuration.

§G ConversationMessage shape (referenced by RFCs 0005 and 0007)

ConversationMessage is the append-only message record for multi-agent communication:

{
  "messageId": "string (required, dedup key, deterministic for replay)",
  "from": "string (agentId or 'user')",
  "to": "string (optional addressee)",
  "groupId": "string (optional, for shared-agent scoping)",
  "content": "any JSON value",
  "ts": "integer (ms epoch)"
}

Messages fold through the applyMessage reducer (channel kind: messages). Replays MUST be deterministic: re-folding the same messageId twice MUST be a no-op.

ConversationTurn (RFC 0005 §C) is a structural superset that adds role, turnIndex, and an optional agent reference.

§B Reasoning events

Five new RunEventType values. All are additive (no v1 reader changes required — readers fold unknown types best-effort per the run-event schema).

agent.reasoned

Emitted when an agent produces a private reasoning trace before acting. Payload:

{
  "agentId": "string",
  "reasoning": "string — the trace itself (summary or full per resolved verbosity)",
  "verbosity": "summary | full | off (optional)"
}

Hosts MUST redact secret material from reasoning before persistence per SR-1 in SECURITY/threat-model-secret-leakage.md. The trace's length is bounded by capabilities.agents.reasoning.tokenLimit (default 512 tokens) when the resolved verbosity is summary. RFC 0024 (separate proposal) adds the optional agent.reasoning.delta sibling event for live-streaming UX while a reasoning block is still open; consumers MAY ignore deltas and read only the closing agent.reasoned for the authoritative content.

Schema-evolution note (2026-05-18). This RFC's prose originally proposed {summary, trace, tokenCount} payload fields. The schema finalized in schemas/run-event-payloads.schema.json ($defs.agentReasoned) uses {reasoning, verbosity} — a tighter, single-field shape that lets a per-run override (RunOptions.configurable.reasoningVerbosity) choose summary vs full vs off at dispatch time. The schema is the normative wire contract; this section was updated to match. Hosts implementing against the original prose MUST migrate to the schema's field names.

agent.toolCalled

Emitted before a tool invocation. Payload:

{
  "agentId": "string",
  "toolId": "string — '<scope>:<tool-id>'",
  "callId": "string — caller-correlated id",
  "arguments": "any JSON value"
}

agent.toolReturned

Emitted after a tool invocation completes. causationId MUST equal the eventId of the corresponding agent.toolCalled — except for a proactive status: 'forbidden' / 'rate_limited' row emitted at agent-loop start before any model call (RFC 0064 §C "forbidden-at-load"), which has no paired agent.toolCalled and MAY omit causationId. Payload:

{
  "agentId": "string",
  "toolId": "string",
  "callId": "string — matches the .toolCalled callId",
  "result": "any JSON value (optional, present on success)",
  "error": "ErrorEnvelope (optional, present on failure)",
  "durationMs": "integer (optional)"
}

agent.handoff

Emitted when one agent transfers control to another within the same node. Payload:

{
  "from": "AgentRef",
  "to": "AgentRef",
  "reason": "string (optional, free-form)",
  "context": "any JSON value (optional, the handoff payload)"
}

agent.decided

Emitted when an agent reaches an actionable decision. Distinct from runOrchestrator.decided (RFC 0006), which is supervisor-level. Payload:

{
  "agentId": "string",
  "decision": "any JSON value (host-defined)",
  "confidence": "number 0..1 (optional)",
  "reasoning": "string (optional)"
}

When confidence is present, hosts MUST apply the §F escalation rules.

§C AgentRef placement on existing event payloads

Three existing payloads gain an optional agent: AgentRef field:

• node.started.payload.agent — the agent the node delegated to.
• node.completed.payload.agent — same, for symmetry.
• RunSnapshot.agent — the run's primary agent (when a single agent owns the run).

All three fields are optional; pre-RFC-0002 events omit them and remain valid against v1 schema.

§D Capability advertisement

Hosts advertise agent-event support via /.well-known/openwop:

{
  "capabilities": {
    "agents": {
      "reasoningEvents": true,
      "toolEvents": true,
      "handoffEvents": true,
      "decisionEvents": true,
      "memoryBackends": ["scratchpad", "conversation", "longTerm"]
    }
  }
}

Clients that consume agent events SHOULD pre-flight via the discovery handshake. Hosts that do not advertise the relevant capability MUST NOT emit the corresponding event type.

Compatibility

Additive. Specifically:

• All five new event types extend the RunEventType union; readers MUST fold unknowns best-effort, so pre-RFC consumers continue to project state correctly.
• All agent fields on existing payloads are optional with no default; absence preserves pre-RFC-0002 behavior.
• The AgentRef shape does not modify any existing required field.
• Capability advertisement is opt-in; hosts that omit capabilities.agents.* are still v1-conformant.

No migration tooling is required.

Conformance

Existing scenarios that exercise the surface today:

• conformance/src/scenarios/identity-passthrough.test.ts — verifies agent field round-trips intact.
• conformance/src/scenarios/multi-node-ordering.test.ts — verifies reasoning event ordering against node.* envelopes.
• conformance/src/scenarios/replayDeterminism.test.ts — verifies replay reproduces agent.reasoned and agent.decided payloads bit-identically (when the host claims replay.cached).

New scenarios required to upgrade from Active to Accepted:

• agent-reasoning-events.test.ts — exercise all five new types against a reference host that advertises capabilities.agents.*.
• agent-confidence-escalation.test.ts — verify the §F escalation contract triggers at the configured threshold.

Both new scenarios MUST gate on capability advertisement (per capabilities-change-detection.md §"Optional capability discovery").

Alternatives considered

1. Embed reasoning in node.completed.payload. Rejected: opacity. A single node may call many tools across many sub-agents; collapsing them all into the node's completion payload loses provenance and breaks per-tool causation chains.
2. **Treat reasoning as a host extension (vendor.openwop.agent.*).** Rejected: every multi-agent host would invent the same shape under a different prefix, fracturing tooling.
3. Borrow LangGraph's messages reducer wholesale. Partially adopted (§G + RFC 0005). Rejected as a sole mechanism because messages is conversation-oriented; reasoning, tool calls, and handoffs need distinct event types for selective subscription via stream-modes.md updates mode.
4. Use A2A AgentCard directly. Rejected: A2A's AgentCard is a _discovery_ shape (capabilities, transport), not a _per-event provenance_ shape. The two surfaces compose (AgentRef references manifest agents that A2A peers can resolve to AgentCards) but are not the same record.

Unresolved questions

1. Should agent.toolReturned.error reuse ErrorEnvelope (current proposal) or a tool-specific variant? Decision: ErrorEnvelope wins for consistency unless tool ecosystems push back.
2. Should agent.reasoned.trace have a normative size cap, or leave that to host policy? Current default: host policy.
3. Should confidence calibration be a closed enum (low/medium/high) instead of [0.0, 1.0]? Closed enum is more portable but loses scoring granularity. Current: numeric range.

Implementation notes (non-normative)

The reference TypeScript host implements AgentRef resolution via a small AgentRegistry populated at workflow registration time. The registry maps agentId → (AgentManifest | HostLocalAgent). Hosts MAY skip the registry and resolve inline at dispatch time; the contract is the wire shape, not the resolver.

Replay determinism: agent.reasoned.trace and agent.toolCalled.arguments MUST be cached at first execution and replayed bit-identically; otherwise replay diverges. See spec/v1/replay.md §"Determinism with non-deterministic agents".

Acceptance criteria

• [x] Spec text merged (this file).
• [x] Schema updated (run-event.schema.json RunEventType enum includes all five agent.* types as of 2026-05-08).
• [x] agent-manifest.schema.json published.
• [ ] At least one conformance scenario covering reasoning-event round-trip.
• [ ] At least one conformance scenario covering §F escalation.
• [ ] CHANGELOG entry under v1.0.
• [ ] Reference host emits all five event types when capabilities.agents.* is advertised.

References

• schemas/agent-manifest.schema.json
• schemas/run-event.schema.json (RunEventType enum)
• schemas/conversation-event.schema.json (consumes §G ConversationMessage shape)
• schemas/conversation-turn.schema.json (structural superset of §G)
• schemas/orchestrator-decision.schema.json (RFC 0006 — consumes §F escalation contract)
• spec/v1/a2a-integration.md (composition with A2A AgentCard)
• RFC 0003 (Agent Packs), RFC 0004 (Memory Layer), RFC 0005 (Conversation), RFC 0006 (Orchestrator), RFC 0007 (Dispatch)