Status: Stable.
This page defines the maturity labels that extension documents carry. Extensions are outside the core profile unless a core document explicitly incorporates them.
Each declared extension has a page at spec/v2/ext/<name>/README.md and a row in ../declaration.json. A row reserves the identifier; it does not make the extension interoperable. Read the individual page to see whether it defines portable behavior or only a discovery claim.
Maturity labels
scripts/check-ext-status-coherence.mjs checks these labels against committed conformance evidence.
Draft
Declared, but without qualifying interoperability evidence.
Predicate: The family is declared in spec/v2/declaration.json with anchor: ext.
Stable
Witnessed: a host at evidence tier 2 or better served it at a certified cut. A certified bundle in evidence/v2-host-bundles/ records the family's declared witness class as satisfied.
Predicate: The family has at least one executed-pass row under its witness id openwop.family.<key>, in a bundle that certifies at least one profile and whose discovery.url origin is listed at tier 2 or better in evidence/host-tiers.json. The seven-day comment window has also run since the promotion PR.
Stable is a historical witness.
- A host's retirement does not demote a family.
- The page's
last witnessed:header row names the newest qualifying bundle, so a
reader can see which host served it and when.
- When no tier-2 or tier-3 host serves, a
Draftfamily cannot graduate until one
does.
The label means only what the family's witness class checks:
witnessable-gatedorseam-gated: the host behaves as the page says.claims-check: the host advertises the reservation in a well-formed record.
Two hosts are not shown to interoperate on it, because the page defines no portable operations.
Retired
Withdrawn: the family is removed from the declaration, and the document names its replacement or the RFC that retired it.
Predicate: The family is absent from the declaration, and the document carries a Superseded by: or Retired by: line.
The check works both ways:
- A
Stabledocument without qualifying evidence fails validation. - A
Draftdocument with qualifying evidence is reported as eligible for
review and promotion.
Note
A directory with no declared family is an implementation or migration note. It carries Status: Note. and MUST say it is not a declared family. It is outside this maturity rule and never becomes Stable. Today the notes are grpc-transport, provider-idempotency, and sandbox-runtime-notes.
What this does not decide
Whether an extension should become core. That takes a separate RFC, normative text, machine-readable contracts, and a behavioral witness.
Sources: RFC 0174, RFC 0177, RFC 0220.